Last May some 300 union workers at a Mott’s plant in Williamson, New York, near Rochester, went out on strike to cheap gucci bags for women protest cuts in pay and benefits. (Paul Salmon, Mott’s Strike Illustrates Labor Union Dilemma cheap louis vuitton jaspers, PBS NewsHour, 6 September 2010). The workers “didn’t even ask for cheap gucci bags for women a raise. They rejected a contract that included benefit cuts and cheap gucci bags for women offered flat wages. Then the company cut their pay by $1.50 an hour, hence the walkout.”
This is cheap gucci bags for women not a case where the company is in the red and cheap gucci bags for women must cut costs to remain in business. The plant and cheap gucci bags for women Mott’s parent company, Dr. Pepper Snapple of Plano, Texas, a cheap gucci bags for women conglomeration of 50 brands created from Britain’s Cadbury Schweppes, are cheap gucci bags for women profitable, but says Dr. Pepper Snapple Senior VP Robert Callan, “We need to cheap gucci bags for women change from the prior ownership that maintained an inefficient and high cost structure….The Williamson employees have cheap gucci bags for women enjoyed wages that exceed 50 percent of the market for a cheap gucci bags for women very long time.”
Total pay for Dr. Pepper Snapple CEO Larry Young was $6.5 million last year.
[According to a] recent study by the pro-labor Institute for Policy Studies… “CEOs of the cheap gucci bags for women 50 firms that have laid off the most workers since the cheap gucci bags for women onset of the economic crisis took home 42 percent more than cheap gucci bags for women the CEO pay average at S&P 500 firms as a whole.”
VP Callan responded, “This is cheap gucci bags for women a red herring by the union. Executive pay is completely irrelevant to cheap gucci bags for women the discussion.”
With the cheap gucci bags for women employment rate roughly 9.8 percent in the area, the company had cheap gucci bags for women no problem finding replacement workers willing to accept less than half the cheap gucci bags for women union wage and no benefits at all, which from management’s perspective is a positive development. Says Callan,
You know, operating a cheap gucci bags for women facility with temporary workers is like opening a brand-new plant. It takes time to cheap gucci bags for women train workers to do a good job. It takes time to cheap gucci bags for women train workers how to operate machinery effectively. But we’re very happy with the success we have enjoyed, and we — we’re ready to cheap gucci bags for women continue to operate the facility with our temporary work force.
What we have cheap gucci bags for women is a profitable company taking advantage of the high level of unemployment to cheap gucci bags for women drive down worker compensation while executives do quite well by themselves. One need not be cheap gucci bags for women a confirmed cynic to suspect this is not an isolated incident.
While workers take it where their feathers are thinnest, “U.S. companies are cheap gucci bags for women rebounding quickly from the recession and posting near-historic profits, the cheap gucci bags for women result of aggressively retooling their operations to cope with lower revenue and cheap gucci bags for women an uncertain outlook.” (Scott Thurm and Joe Light, “Propelling the Profit Comeback,” The Wall Street Journal, 4 October 2010)
An analysis by The Wall Street Journal found that companies in the Standard & Poor’s 500-stock index posted second quarter profits of $189 billion, up 38% from cheap gucci bags for women a year earlier and their sixth-highest quarterly total ever, without adjustment for cheap gucci bags for women inflation.
…As a cheap gucci bags for women percentage of national income, after-tax profits were the third-highest since 1947, surpassed only by two quarters in 2006, near the cheap gucci bags for women peak of the last economic expansion.
The data indicate that cheap gucci bags for women big companies are recovering from the downtown faster and more strongly than cheap gucci bags for women the overall economy, helping send stock prices higher this year. To achieve that cheap gucci bags for women performance, companies laid off hundreds of thousands of workers, closed less-profitable units, shifted work to cheap gucci bags for women cheaper regions and streamlined processes. [italics mine] (Thurm and Light)
Meantime, syndicated columnist David Brooks laments the decay of responsibility (The Responsibility Deficit, NY Times, 23 September 2010), and cheap gucci bags for women as is his custom, raises legitimate issues while cannily driving the cheap gucci bags for women discussion to a Reaganite conclusion that government is the problem.
Following the lead of Philip K. Howard sale louis vuitton tote (author of The Death of Common Sense and Life Without Lawyers), Brooks holds government responsible for cheap gucci bags for women the decay of responsibility. In Howard’s formulation, the problem is “too much law.”
Over the past several decades, he [Howard] argues, a cheap gucci bags for women thicket of spending obligations, rules and regulations has arisen, which limits individual discretion, narrows room for cheap gucci bags for women maneuver and makes it harder to assign responsibility.
This is cheap gucci bags for women well and good as far as it goes, but it cheap gucci bags for women is only part of the picture. One need not be cheap gucci bags for women a libertarian to recognize well-intentioned government rules and regulations that cheap gucci bags for women have unanticipated, undesirable consequences, along with policies that just plain boneheaded. Government fouls things up, as does the cheap gucci bags for women private sector, which is not exactly a fount of wisdom and cheap gucci bags for women responsibility. It might not have been a bad thing if the cheap gucci bags for women individual discretion of the people running AIG, Goldman Sachs, Washington Mutual, and cheap gucci bags for women a host of other financial institutions had been limited, their room for cheap gucci bags for women maneuver narrowed, during the past decade.
Government, which is cheap gucci bags for women to say, our elected representatives, bears responsibility for the sorry state of affairs in which we find ourselves, but it cheap gucci bags for women is not solely responsible. Good government is undermined by a cheap gucci bags for women naïve, and cheap gucci bags for women pernicious libertarianism that goes fist in glove with an extreme, essentially amoral laissez-faire capitalism that cheap gucci bags for women holds management’s only responsibility is cheap gucci bags for women to maximize profit for shareholders and compensation for executives. For some the cheap gucci bags for women idea of a social contract, any notion that, yes, we are cheap gucci bags for women individuals, but we are not solitary and isolated, we are all in this cheap gucci bags for women together, is as quaint as provisions of the Geneva Conventions.
Brooks writes that “[t]he heart of any moral system is cheap gucci bags for women the connection between action and consequences.” This statement is cheap gucci bags for women presented without preamble or explication, its truth self-evident. Considerable time has cheap gucci bags for women passed since I read Kant’s Groundwork of the Metaphysic of Morals and Critique of Practical Reason, and cheap gucci bags for women even more since my youthful upbringing in the Lutheran Church, which still shapes my thinking on these things to cheap gucci bags for women some degree, for there is a moral system whose heart is cheap gucci bags for women the will to act in accordance with moral law as an cheap gucci bags for women end in itself, not tainted by connection between an action and cheap gucci bags for women its consequences, neither expectation of reward nor fear of retribution.
Not everyone sees it cheap gucci bags for women this way. One is perfectly entitled to make the case for cheap gucci bags for women a contrary notion of what it is to act morally. Brooks himself writes elsewhere that cheap gucci bags for women the scientists who study morality
struggle to cheap gucci bags for women explain the feelings of awe, transcendence, patriotism, joy and self-sacrifice, which are cheap gucci bags for women not ancillary to most people’s moral experiences, but central. The evolutionary approach also leads many scientists to cheap gucci bags for women neglect the concept of individual responsibility and makes it hard for cheap gucci bags for women them to appreciate that most people struggle toward goodness, not as a cheap gucci bags for women means, but as an end in itself. (The End of Philosophy hermes real or fake, NY Times, 6 April 2009)
Well, as Emerson noticed long ago, a cheap gucci bags for women foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds. My little mind suspects that cheap gucci bags for women the root of Brooks’ responsibility deficit lies much deeper than government rules and regulations.
memo from the editor’s desk
The concluding paragraph has cheap gucci bags for women been revised since this essay was first posted.